How to Choose a Pickleball Paddle: The Complete Buyer's Guide
Walk into any pickleball shop or browse online, and you'll find hundreds of paddles ranging from $30 to $300. How do you possibly choose?
The best paddle isn't the most expensive one. It's the one that matches your game and feels like an extension of your arm.
This guide will help you cut through the marketing noise and find what actually works for you.
The Four Factors That Actually Matter
Everything else is secondary. Get these four right, and you'll have a paddle you love.
Factor 1: Weight
Paddle weight ranges from about 6 to 14 ounces. Here's how to choose:
Lightweight Paddles (Under 7.3 oz)
Lightweight paddles offer quick reactions and easy maneuvering, but less power. Best for control players, those with arm issues, and beginners learning technique.
Lightweight paddles are easier on your arm and shoulder, give you faster hand speed at the net, and cause less fatigue during long sessions. However, they provide less power on drives, more vibration on off-center hits, and may feel insubstantial to some players.
Midweight Paddles (7.3-8.3 oz)
The sweet spot for most players. Midweight paddles balance power and control, making them suitable for all-around play. This is the most popular weight range for good reason.
When in doubt, start with midweight. You can always add lead tape to increase weight, but you can't remove weight from a heavy paddle.
Heavyweight Paddles (Over 8.3 oz)
Heavyweight paddles deliver more power with less effort, but require more strength to maneuver quickly. Best for power players, baseline drivers, and stronger athletes.
Heavy paddles give you more power with less swing effort, better stability on hard shots, and fewer vibrations. The trade-off is they're slower at the net, cause more arm fatigue, and make it harder to reset quickly after shots.
Factor 2: Grip Size
Grip circumference typically ranges from 4 inches to 4.5 inches. The right size is crucial for comfort and injury prevention.
Finding Your Grip Size
- 1Measure from the tip of your ring finger to the bottom crease of your palm
- 2This measurement in inches is approximately your ideal grip size
- 3Most adults fall between 4.0 and 4.5 inches
- 4When between sizes, go smaller since you can add overgrip later
A grip that's too small can cause wrist strain and lead to over-gripping, though some players prefer this for added spin. A grip that's too large restricts wrist movement, makes grip changes harder, and causes more arm strain over time.
Most players can adapt to a range of sizes. If you're between 4.125 and 4.25 inches, either will work fine. Personal preference matters more at that point.
Factor 3: Core Material
The core is the inside of the paddle that determines feel and performance.
Polymer Honeycomb Core
This is the most common core material on the market today. Polymer cores produce a quieter sound, offer a softer feel, provide good control, and come in a wide power range from soft to firm.
Polymer cores dominate the market for good reason: they work well for everyone and come in many variations to match different playing styles.
Nomex Honeycomb Core
Nomex is the hardest core material available. It produces a loud, distinctive pop sound and delivers maximum power at the expense of some control. This is the preferred choice for power-focused players.
Aluminum Core
Aluminum cores are a lightweight option that offers good control but less power. This material is less common in modern paddles but still has its place for specific playing styles.
Factor 4: Face Material
The paddle face affects power, spin, and overall durability.
Fiberglass Face
Fiberglass faces provide more power with a softer feel on contact. They offer less precise control but are generally less expensive, making them good for beginners to intermediate players.
Carbon Fiber or Graphite Face
Carbon fiber paddles deliver more control and precision placement with a stiffer feel. These are preferred by advanced players and generally cost more.
Carbon fiber paddles often have textured surfaces for enhanced spin. If spin is important to your game, look for paddles advertising spin technology.
Composite Face
Composite faces blend multiple materials for balanced performance. They offer a wide variety of options and serve as a good middle ground choice for players who want versatility.
Paddle Shapes Explained
Standard Shape
The traditional paddle shape offers a balanced sweet spot and works well for all-around play. This is the most forgiving shape for developing players.
Elongated Shape
Elongated paddles have a longer face that provides more reach and is more power-focused. The trade-off is a smaller sweet spot that requires more precise contact.
Wide Body Shape
Wide body paddles have a larger hitting surface with a bigger sweet spot. They're more forgiving on off-center hits and excellent for beginners.
Start with a standard shape unless you have a specific reason to go elongated. The larger sweet spot reduces mishits while you develop your technique.
Price Points: What You Actually Get
Budget Range ($30-80)
Budget paddles are fine for absolute beginners who are trying the sport. They use functional but basic materials and will likely need upgrading as your skills improve.
Don't spend $200 your first month playing. A $50 paddle is perfectly adequate for learning the fundamentals of the game.
Mid-Range ($80-150)
This is the sweet spot for most players. Mid-range paddles use quality materials, deliver good performance, and will last for years of regular play.
Premium Range ($150-250+)
Premium paddles feature advanced materials and construction with marginal improvements over mid-range options. They're worth the investment for competitive players and often include paddle warranties.
Recommendations by Skill Level
For Beginners
- 1Choose midweight (7.5-8.0 oz) for learning proper technique
- 2Select a wider shape for a larger sweet spot
- 3Look for polymer core for forgiving feel
- 4Stay in the budget to mid-range price point
For Intermediate Players
Explore different weights based on your developing style. Consider an elongated shape if you want more reach, or a carbon fiber face if control is becoming your priority. Mid-range price point offers the best value at this level.
For Advanced Players
At the advanced level, specificity matters most. Know exactly what you want from your paddle. Choose weight based on your established game style, and consider premium materials for marginal gains that matter in competitive play.
Many pro shops and clubs offer demo programs. Test paddles before you buy, especially at higher price points where the investment is significant.
Demo Before You Buy
The best way to choose a paddle is to try them in actual play. Visit pro shops with demo programs, borrow paddles from friends, attend paddle demo events, and play at least 3-4 sessions with a paddle before making your decision.
Find paddle demo events near you on Picklebeast, or ask your local club about their demo program.
Get StartedCommon Mistakes to Avoid
Many players make these errors when choosing their first paddle: buying based on brand name alone, choosing a paddle because a pro uses it, spending too much as a beginner, ignoring grip size entirely, and not trying paddles before buying.
Final Thoughts
Your paddle should disappear in your hand. When you stop thinking about your equipment and just play, you've found the right one.
Start with the fundamentals: right weight, right grip, quality construction. Let your game develop, then refine your choice as you understand what you need. The perfect paddle is out there waiting for you.
Ready to organize your next game?
Download Picklebeast and start finding players, running leagues, and hosting tournaments.
Get the App